Voldemort looked like a terrifying terrorist genius in Magical Britain because he'd been able to figure out basic concepts like "home invasion" and "let's all wear masks".Ĭlick to expand.I can entirely imagine how to dismantle the statute of secrecy without cooperation from the wizarding world - all I need is a very low finite # of wizards willing to go against their own governments, for my demonstrations. Tactically, you can find street gang leaders in any large American city that have more savvy re: asymmetrical warfare than he did. Wizards are hilariously shitty at counterinsurgency warfare. Governments have long since found the solution to this problem make sure the guys out at the sharp end only know what's in their little compartment. So? While the time scale is indeed much faster, similar problems exist IRL re: "assuming your enemy has no scruples at all, you must assume that anyone they catch alive will crack". red fish that are busy hiding in a sea of six billion red fish.Īnd yes, wizards can read minds and have Veritaserum. If they try Plan God-King, they're fighting on the worst possible ground for them - with the wizards out in the open, vs. The main problems with wizards, as itemized, is their ability to hide. I think the ideal would be to dismantle the statue of secrecy in a safe, controlled way while integrating wizards back into human society, but I can't imagine how you would do that without a high degree of cooperation from the wizarding world.Ĭlick to expand.I disagree. That leads to a better world for non-magicals how, exactly? Or the plans to destabilize wizard government by turning them against each other. And the sort of intrusive security measures necessary to hunt them down (because I know someone is going to detail a plan to do so) would make the current NSA surveillance state look like civil liberties paradise. Morality aside, that leads 5% who are really pissed off and feel free to do whatever the hell they want to muggles. I mean, suppose you launched some kind of alpha-murder strike that killed 95% of wizards. Yes the mass mind control/memory alteration is horrible, but it's in service to a societal norm that discourages wizards from mixing with non-magicals and outright forbids, say, openly ruling over them as god-kings. Tearing down the existing wizarding society is likely to lead to a worse world than you have right now. I think the trickiest part of all this is deciding what you want your ideal world to look like at the end of it all. For every Hermione or Snape who actually applies common sense even semi-consistently, there are a huge numbers of wizards with all the wisdom of an adult in a Roald Dahl novel. If they have a weakness, it isn't that avada kedavra is no stronger than a gun, but that most wizards are silly, illogical fools with next to no demonstrated ability to leverage their vast powers in optimal fashion. So despite the lack of raw firepower, I think the wizarding world would pose an enormous challenge to any hostile muggle force. They can pretty quickly figure out whatever their muggle opponents might be planning. Making sure everything goes you way has terrifying implications when applied to war. They also have a demonstrated ability to completely screw with electronics and technology, as shown by the Hogwarts grounds (so its a good bet you can't exactly fine Hogwarts with a drone or google earht). Its not just that an individual wizard can become invisible, turn into an animal, or impersonate someone else-they can hide entire neighborhoods in the cracks between buildings behind a dingy London pub (Diagon Alley), make entire estates impossible to see, find or track on a map without knowing what you're looking for (Hogwarts), packs the interior of a large building into a small folding tent (Hermione does this, as do the Weasleys at the Quidditch World Cup), and stuff a train platform into some kind of pocket dimension inside a larger station such that nobody but wizards can access it and nobody sees or notices the train itself at any point, not even when its pulled out of the station (platform 9 3/4 and the Hogwarts Express). An incredible ability to hide in plain sight via illusions, manipulating pocket dimensions and space, etc.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |